Gaslighters Unanimous

According to the editors, Sean Carleton and Niigaan Sinclair, “Residential school denialism is on the rise … and has been growing in intensity after the Tk’mlups te Secwepemc (TTS) announcement in 2021 about the location of potential unmarked graves at the Kamloops Indian Residential School.” Carleton and Sinclair define residential school denialism as “the rejection, minimization, distortion, or misrepresentation of basic facts about residential schooling to shake public confidence in the truth and undermine reconciliation efforts. It is part of a broader assault on Indigenous Peoples,” (P. 3).

To counter residential school denialism, Carleton and Sinclair co-edited a collection of essays and interviews (Truth Before Reconciliation: Confronting Residential School Denialism, 2026; University of Manitoba Press). Readers are assured, repeatedly, that this is an anonymously peer-reviewed work  by “three expert reviewers.” Peer-reviewing interviews seems novel to this writer.

Residential school denialism is a neologism that intentionally draws upon Holocaust denial to appropriate the opprobrium generally assigned to Holocaust denial and to also attribute an equivalence of suffering to residential school ‘Survivors.’ To be sure, the editors and contributors are all convinced that the schools were a genocide and regard anyone questioning that assessment as moral reprobates. As Kisha Supernant puts it, denialists “are just people who are unwilling to accept the truth that Canada is built on genocide … because they are so invested in the project of settler colonialism and the erasure of Indigenous Peoples. These are people who want that project to continue,” (Pp. 166-7). Thus, Supernant renders denialists as co-genocidaires.

Carleton and Sinclair waste no time in declaring Canada’s genocidal guilt while displaying a readiness to alter the record for the sake of their rhetoric. In the second paragraph of their introduction, they write that the Final Report (2015) of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission “showed Canadians the evidence of how residential schooling constituted genocide,” (P. 1). The TRC concluded that the schools were a “cultural genocide,” which is meaningless in law and carries no legal test. This naked revision by Carleton and Sinclair is an indication of how much caution the reader should proceed with. Their book generally suffers from being a hymnal for the choir: they don’t respect their critics and, in the main, the contributors excuse themselves from dealing academically with their critics.

The editors and contributors place Canadians in one of three categories: those that agree with their truth; those that are too ignorant or miseducated to agree with their truth; and denialists. Their truth is that the schools were a genocide whose negative effects have rippled through subsequent generations (euphemistically known as ‘intergenerational trauma’).

Six of the thirteen chapters are just interviews between the editors and often several individuals. The first chapter, for example, is an interview with the Orange Shirt story’s creator, Phyllis Webstad, presumably intended to set the tone for the rest of the book: “The genocide in Canada against Indigenous Peoples is not complete. It’s ongoing. Denialism is the last step in genocide, a last gasp for control over Indigenous Peoples by undermining our experience,” (P. 38). No dates are given for when these interviews were conducted nor is there any disclosure on how they were conducted. The interviews read more like tailored scripts rather than as candid remarks.

Some of the chapters resemble academic essays with authors and actual works being cited. A chapter by Lindsay Gibson and James Miles presents a practical strategy for ‘confronting denialism’ in the form of a pedagogical innovation, the “5Ds: detect, debunk, disregard, debate and deconstruct,” (Pp.135-56). Gibson and Miles at least allow that people should debate the questions raised by the denialists – the rest of the book’s contributors want the 6th D: detention.

Michelle Good’s chapter, “Residential School Denialism is a Crime” (it isn’t and the wording of this chapter title should have been corrected), is an opinion piece which gives her some rhetorical licence (Pp. 201-10). She takes that licence to extremes, however: “What, we must ask, distinguishes between the genocide of World War II (a grossly misleading reference to the Nazi Holocaust) and the genocide that occurred in Canada during the years of operation of the IRS system? The answer, of course, is that there is little distinction other than means and magnitude,” (P. 202; emphasis mine). Good, as others do, inadvertently trivializes the Holocaust by appropriating its languages and images and comparing it to a schooling program where children could go home for holidays and even graduate out of. The Holocaust resulted in 6 million deaths; only 423 students are known to have died at the schools, none of whom were murdered. Saying that means and magnitude do not really matter is unconscionably disrespectful but we are talking about minds for whom genocide is a conceit.

On the matter of minimizing the Holocaust, Woolford goes one step further: “It would seem … that one cannot acknowledge the distinct genocide experiences in both the Holocaust and the IRS system. We are dragged back into the tired uniqueness debate, which holds the Holocaust as, if not the only genocide, at minimum one that should be treated as incomparable to others,” Pp. 192-3; emphasis added). The Holocaust is unique because it is the only genocide in human history that slaughtered people on an industrial scale. Remember: Woolford bills himself as a genocide scholar. One wonders about the expert peer reviewers who let that howler pass.

We perhaps owe those reviewers some thanks in advising Carleton to at least present readers with some of the actual text from the infamous May 27, 2021 announcement (P. 167): “… the stark truth of the preliminary findings came to light – the confirmation of the remains of 215 children who were students at the Kamloops Indian Residential School.” TTS added: “We had a knowing in our community that we were able to verify … Some were as young as three years old.”

Although the language in the announcement is unambiguous in declaring the discovery of children’s remains, Carleton et al have since taken to rephrasing the announcement as the locating of “potential unmarked graves” and Chief Casimir herself has reclassified her band’s findings as “anomalies,” (isn’t that minimizing the supposed harm). Carleton stresses the word, “preliminary” as if that somehow makes the initial announcement read less certain than it was originally stated. What exactly is the potential for those anomalies to be clandestine graves? There isn’t a corresponding number of children known to have gone unaccountably missing from the school; there are no related historic missing child reports filed with the RCMP (two more points omitted by all in the book).

The potential for unmarked graves to be located in the old orchard at the former residential school is about the same as for your backyard. Unless you excavate, you cannot definitively rule out the possibility that there are graves in your backyard. Carleton relies heavily on omission for rhetorical purposes. He does not inform the reader or explain why the 215 number was subsequently reduced to 200 or why he and Chief Casimir insist on still using the 215 number. Nowhere in the book does any contributor mention that the ‘potential unmarked graves’ detected by ground penetrating radar (GPR) could very well be old septic tiles from a 1924 septic field installation on the same site. The belief that three year-old children could be buried in the orchard is most likely a false interpretation of those old septic tiles (three year-olds weren’t allowed to enroll in the schools and would only have been admitted for child welfare reasons). Nowhere in the book is it mentioned that Simon Fraser University conducted unrelated digs on the same site years earlier and that Sarah Beaulieu’s GPR scan picked up 15 ‘shadows’ of those digs. Given that sample, it can be reasonably inferred that there probably aren’t human remains in the other 200 GPR blips. The SFU results were known to TTS years before the Spring of 2021 so just how did TTS come to the conclusion that there must be hidden bodies there?

The editors’ rhetorical strategy is clear: the less people know of the facts, the more likely they are to believe the fables.

Carleton’s chapter (a reworked essay he co-wrote with Reid Gerbrandt; pp. 157-82) exemplifies this strategy. Carleton and Gerbrand took a statement made by Terry Glavin in his National Post article, “Year of the Graves,” and incorporated it as their thesis: Were claims of a mass grave being found almost universally reported in the media? Carleton and Gerbrandt confined their search for reportage to five Canadian media outlets and came to the conclusion that the mass grave feature wasn’t universally reported. The authors ignore the elephant in the room: the New York Times was the first newspaper to run a headline of a mass grave being found at one of Canada’s former residential schools. NYT ran Ian Austen’s article (“Horrible History: Mass Grave of Indian Children Reported in Canada”) the day after the Kamloops announcement. Reputable news organizations typically insist on two sources of verification before running a story. If the Kamloops announcement didn’t mention a mass grave, how did Austen come to the conclusion that one had been found (I asked Mr. Austen to clarify that but he never replied)? Did someone involved with Tk’emlups notify Austen prior to the May 27, 2021 announcement and tell him that a mass grave had been found or did Austen falsely conclude that on his own?

Carleton and Gerbrandt also omit to mention that a group of lawyers filed a complaint with the International Criminal Court against Canada, the Vatican and the RCMP a few days after the May 27, 2021 announcement in which they stated that a mass grave had been found and that more were likely to be found. An even more egregious omission is not mentioning that Chief Roseanne Casimir herself, after telling the press that her band had not found a mass grave, presented a motion to the Assembly Of First Nations stating that they had found a mass grave. She presented a similar motion several weeks later to the BCAFN declaring that “unmarked mass graves were located” at the former Kamloops IRS. In light of those omissions, it is hypocritical of Carleton to accuse the so-called denialists of ‘cherry-picking’ the facts.

Carleton admits that he, too, once tweeted about this mass grave (P. 172). Interestingly, at the book launch for Truth Before Reconciliation and in subsequent press interviews, co-editor Sinclair has repeatedly insisted that ‘mass grave’ is an appropriate term to be used, forcing Carleton to stifle his chagrin as Sinclair basically argued that a cemetery could be considered a mass grave because a lot of people are buried in one area.

Ever since the conceit of genocide was linked to residential schools, activist academics have been unable to resist comparisons to the Holocaust. They first appropriated words from the lexicon of Holocaust study with ‘Survivor’ being the ready example. However, the metaphorical exegesis of the Holocaust trope has inevitably led them to use ‘mass grave’ and even the image of infants being burned in incinerators to depict the schools as veritable death camps, if not the archetype for the Nazi Vernichtungslagers.

Several contributors call for the criminalization of residential school denialism in the same way that Holocaust denial is illegal. Chapter 10  by Leah Gazan (my MP, actually; pp.211-21) is the most ardent in calling for critics of the IRS genocide narrative to be jailed. Referring to the known cemeteries attached to several of the schools in truly sophomoric outrage, Gazan fulminates: “The fact that many residential schools had cemeteries and nobody questioned that is a problem to me. And this whole move to intellectualizing the experience of residential school like it’s a study – it’s not. It’s a lived experience that has reverberating impacts in our blood memory as Indigenous Peoples,” (P. 216). Gazan has nominal aboriginal ancestry but her identification with the victim group is professionally and politically useful.

Like Michelle Good, Gazan insists that Canada and the churches involved with the schools committed all five acts of genocide described in Article II of the UN Convention on the Punishment and Prevention of the Crime of Genocide. It is in Gazan’s chapter that the conceit of genocide is revealed as unhinged hubris: “But there has been a normalization of genocide against Indigenous Peoples to the point that people flippantly deny the genocide that has been perpetrated against us – residential schooling being one among many genocides,” (P. 215). Absolute victimhood breeds absolute entitlement and genocide is absolute victimhood so bad actors like Gazan grasp for the conceit of genocide.

Having borrowed so heavily from the Holocaust trope, the editors and contributors are confronted with a deficit of moral equivalency that they cannot possibly reconcile so they prevaricate with semantic chicanery and, when that fails, they seek to proscribe with the gavel, tar and feathers.

For the record, no party has ever been convicted for committing all five acts of genocide. The editors and contributors are convinced that Canada is guilty of a genocide that is historic in its proportions (history’s longest running genocide with all 5 acts committed) but that is the logical course of their common ideology of decolonization: Canada is to be absolutely deconstructed as a nation-state founded on genocide. The problem is that the editors and contributors reached that conclusion on a presumption of guilt and succumbed to confirmation bias where outright demagoguery didn’t prevail. Having invested so much personally in that conclusion, they regard it as morally reprehensible for anyone to speak in defense of Canada and the churches after the fact.

Woolford, for example, comments on how definitionalism is one of the tools that denialists use to deny that residential schools were genocide. As has been his academic wont for many years now, Woolford has sought to define genocide beyond what it has been codified as in law in order to condemn Canada. If the idea is to successfully prosecute parties for committing genocide, a precise legal definition of the crime is required. Woolford specifically focuses on the destruction of culture in his definition of genocide. With respect to most of the schools, they were Christian-run and parents enrolled their children according to their faith, however nominal that might have been. If the parents had adopted a Christian faith, they inexorably adopted some of its culture. Culture isn’t a static and finite mass as Woolford sees it. The schools didn’t replace the traditional culture of a child, they simply added more to the aggregate of the individual. As each of us could personally attest to, you don’t lose the sense of who you are by learning something outside of yourself. Perhaps, in Woolford’s mind, aboriginal people can’t internally accommodate cultural diversity the way he can?

For all the lauding of their book as being peer-reviewed, it is striking that those peers didn’t draw attention to a glaring omission in Kimberly Murray’s concluding chapter. While the former Special Interlocutor for Missing Children In Unmarked Graves and Burial Sites Associated with Indian Residential Schools tells us that she feels that “Canada has legal, ethical and moral obligations to continue supporting communities as they search for missing and unmarked burials (P. 278),” she doesn’t explain that the children aren’t really missing as she informed the Standing Senate committee on Indigenous People in 2023: “There are no missing children; they’re buried in the cemeteries. They’re missing because parents were never told where they’re buried.” In other words, they are only figuratively missing and Murray has also done this with her claim of “enforced disappearances” from the schools.

To date there has been no positive identification of any unmarked burial sites related to the IRS. There has been lots of conflation with unmarked graves, however, which are lawful graves that simply became unmarked over time for one reason or another. The absence of any actual unmarked burials hasn’t deterred Murray or Carleton et al from speaking as if they exist much in the same way that the fact of deaths at the schools is insinuated as foul play.

It is disingenuous rhetoric from an activist clique that was thrilled to hear news of children’s remains being found at a former residential school because here, finally, was evidence of actual genocide and not the figurative genocide of culture. Take Niigaan Sinclair as an example of someone whose professional and public life has soared since May 27, 2021 but who was long before convinced that the schools were a genocide; the news of bodies being found was both enriching and validating. Faced with the exposure posed by the so-called denialists, he resorts to dismissiveness and doubles down. Saying the schools weren’t a genocide is like denying that gravity exists and, yes, there are mass graves at former schools. He bluffs with outward umbrage like his co-editor and the other contributors do but indignation isn’t an argument and most of these actors are supposed to be academics, vetted and credentialed no less.

The shame of Truth Before Reconciliation is that, when confronted with the reality of increasing residential school ‘denialism’, the editors and contributors resort to gaslighting instead of reconsidering their positions. Their case isn’t helped by the shifty temporizing of Chief Casimir after her band received millions in federal funding to conduct excavations and possibly, exhumations, if remains were found. 5 ½ years after Casimir confirmed the discovery of children’s remains, it is increasingly difficult for even the sympathetic observer to reconcile the initial claim with the ongoing absence of evidence, particularly given the slogan, “Every Child Matters.” After all this time, shouldn’t we have even one name of a missing and presumably murdered child who might be unlawfully buried in the old school orchard?

Truth Before Reconciliation offers little of the former and none of the latter and I would advise the reader to consider the book as a study in rhetoric crafted by like-minded authors fighting against being disabused of their IRS genocide narrative. What you read here is curated towards an objective of criminalizing critical examination of highly sensational claims and is not, in itself, a reliable source of information about what did and did not happen in the schools. The editors and authors rely upon what the reader doesn’t know about the schools.

 

More content

Trending
Also in
Also from Michael Melanson
Latest

More content

Trending
Also in
Also from Michael Melanson
Latest

Comments

Don't miss out.

Join the conversation with other IRSRG readers. Subscribe to leave a comment.

Already a subscriber? Log in